Chocolate chunks with brown background
Whole pepper for Spicy Kick Peanut Butter
Maple Syrup used to sweeten peanut butter Vanilla beans with white background
Whole cinnamon sticks arranged on a flat surface
Roasted peanuts scattered on white background

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Slow Roasted

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Small batch

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Simply delicious

Chocolate Mint Crunch

A seasonal favorite

Pre-order now for November 1st shipping.

Creamy Peanut Butter
Premium Milk Chocolate
Organic Peppermint Bits
Limited Seasonal Flavor

What makes us so good? Peanut Butter Guy

We use a premium peanut variety called High Oleic, which contains more of the heart healthy "good" fat compared to regular peanuts. Then we slow roast to perfection for a richer more nuttier taste. Finally we use only all natural ingredients in each of our unique flavor varieties.

PLUS, every jar is made fresh and shipped fresh! That's why we say "it really is Good Stuff."

Good peanut butter. Great Customers!

Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich

Discover the key advantages of our all natural peanut butter, crafted to elevate your health and taste experience with premium quality:


Healthier Fat Profile:
Our high oleic peanut butter is made from a special variety of peanuts naturally rich in monounsaturated fats, particularly oleic acid. These heart-healthy fats help improve cholesterol levels and reduce the risk of cardiovascular diseases, making our healthy peanut butter a smarter choice. With less saturated fat and more monounsaturated fats than traditional peanut butter, our high oleic peanut butter is perfect for those prioritizing heart health.


Best Tasting Peanut Butter with Superior Texture:
Experience the smooth, creamy peanut butter texture of our high oleic peanut butter, perfect for spreading on toast, crackers, or fruit. The higher monounsaturated fat content creates a luxurious, spreadable consistency that sets it apart. Plus, its milder, slightly sweeter flavor makes it the best tasting peanut butter for those who prefer a less intense peanut taste. For those who love a bit of texture, our crunchy peanut butter delivers the same great taste with a satisfying crunch.


Nutritional Powerhouse:
Our high protein peanut butter retains all the nutritional benefits of traditional peanut butter while offering a healthier fat profile. Packed with plant-based protein, dietary fiber, and essential nutrients like vitamin E, magnesium, and potassium, it’s a nutrient-dense choice. Plus, it contains beneficial plant compounds like resveratrol, an antioxidant that supports overall wellness. Whether you choose our creamy peanut butter or chocolate peanut butter, you’re getting a wholesome, healthy peanut butter option.


Stability and Pet Safe
Thanks to the high oleic peanuts used in our all natural peanut butter, this product boasts enhanced stability and a longer shelf life. The monounsaturated fats are more resistant to oxidation than the polyunsaturated fats in regular peanut butter, reducing the risk of rancidity. This makes our high oleic peanut butter a convenient choice for those who enjoy peanut butter occasionally or in smaller quantities. It’s also pet safe peanut butter, so you can share a little with your furry friends (in moderation, of course)!


Versatile for Cooking and Baking:
Our high oleic peanut butter shines in the kitchen with its stability at high temperatures, making it ideal for cooking and baking. From stir-fries and sauces to baked goods and desserts, this healthy peanut butter adds a deliciously mild flavor and smooth texture. Try our cinnamon roll crunch peanut butter for a unique twist in sweet recipes or our chocolate peanut butter for decadent treats. Whether you’re whipping up savory dishes or indulging in sweets, our creamy peanut butter and crunchy peanut butter varieties are versatile ingredients that elevate every recipe.