Creamy - 16oz.

Silky smooth, rich, and roasted just right. Our Creamy peanut butter starts with fresh-ground High Oleic peanuts, slow roasted in small batches for a deeper, nuttier flavor. Then we add a touch of wood smoked maple syrup for a one-of-a-kind taste you won't find on a grocery store shelf.

•  High Oleic peanuts: a premium peanut variety naturally higher in monounsaturated fat

•  Small batch and slow roasted in North Carolina

•  All natural ingredients

•  Made fresh, shipped fresh to your door

Try it on: toast, apples and bananas, oatmeal, smoothies, or straight off the spoon.

FREE Shipping with total order of $48 or more.

You can send your order to anyone directly as a gift. Provide a short greeting and we will take care of the rest. Check the "Send this order as a gift" box and provide their ship-to address at checkout.

Nutrition Information

* Serving size : 2  Tablespoons

  • Calories : 190
  • Monounsaturated Fat : 12g
  • Other Fat : 2.5g
  • Cholesterol : 0mg
  • Sodium : 100mg
  • Carbohydrates : 8g
  • Fiber : 2g
  • Sugar : 3g
  • Protein : 9g

Creamy - 16oz.

Skip to product information
1 of 1
Regular price $10.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
Sale Sold out

Creamy - 16oz.

Silky smooth, rich, and roasted just right. Our Creamy peanut butter starts with fresh-ground High Oleic peanuts, slow roasted in small batches for a deeper, nuttier flavor. Then we add a touch of wood smoked maple syrup for a one-of-a-kind taste you won't find on a grocery store shelf.

•  High Oleic peanuts: a premium peanut variety naturally higher in monounsaturated fat

•  Small batch and slow roasted in North Carolina

•  All natural ingredients

•  Made fresh, shipped fresh to your door

Try it on: toast, apples and bananas, oatmeal, smoothies, or straight off the spoon.

FREE Shipping with total order of $48 or more.

You can send your order to anyone directly as a gift. Provide a short greeting and we will take care of the rest. Check the "Send this order as a gift" box and provide their ship-to address at checkout.

Nutrition Information

* Serving size : 2  Tablespoons

  • Calories : 190
  • Monounsaturated Fat : 12g
  • Other Fat : 2.5g
  • Cholesterol : 0mg
  • Sodium : 100mg
  • Carbohydrates : 8g
  • Fiber : 2g
  • Sugar : 3g
  • Protein : 9g

Clean Ingredients

  • High Oleic Peanuts
  • Organic Maple Syrup
  • Fine Sea Salt

Available in jars of:

  • 16 oz.
View full details
Regular price $10.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
Sale Sold out
  • 5 stars: 43 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
A
April Clement
This is the best Peanut Butter

This is the best Peanut Butter. I can't find another with this kind of quality and ingredients I feel good about. So delicious, too!

L
Lori D
This has become my and my son's favorite peanut butter! I will never go back to any others

This has become my and my son's favorite peanut butter! I will never go back to any others.

A
Anonymous
Fresh and great taste

Fresh and great taste!

J
Janet Bland
This peanut butter is so good

This peanut butter is so good. Full of nuts and very crunchy.

A
Anonymous
Excellent product

Excellent product. Best PB is have had yet.

A
Anonymous
Love this stuff

I've eaten a lot of peanut butter over the years, but this is clearly the best, better than anything you can buy in a grocery store. And its high oleic content makes it healthier.

T
Taylor Atwater
This PB is stellar! It tastes creamy

This PB is stellar! It tastes creamy, and so much better than store-bought PB.

L
Lynn Stone
Absolutely fantastic peanut butter

Absolutely fantastic peanut butter. Makes the best PB&J ever!

A
Anonymous
I love this peanut butter

I love this peanut butter.i enjoy it on apple slices as a healthy snack. I am so glad you were featured in an Our State Magazine article, or I would never have discovered your great company.

D
Debra Danner
Love it as a snack

If I need something like a snack I eat a spoonful and I’m satisfied. I love it!

D
Debra Danner
A treat!

A spoonful is my snack!

G
Garry Vreugdenhil
Very good tasting product

Very good tasting product.

B
Barbara Perry
Fantastic!

Fantastic! Eat it with a spoon!

H
Hank Davis
Best peanut butter I ever had

Best peanut butter I ever had.

E
Elizabeth Riggs
Very good peanut butter & love the crunchy kind

Very good peanut butter & love the crunchy kind. No need to stir!

K
Kathy Castrigno
perfect spice

perfect spice. I really like this stuff!

L
LG Moore
Best peanut butter ever! That is all I

Best peanut butter ever! That is all I order!

K
Kimberly Daily
Good-for-you peanut butter!

I had been limiting my PB&J sandwiches because of all the palm oil in the usual peanut butters. But not now! I was persuaded to try this peanut butter at a maker’s market and it’s exactly what I’ve been looking for. Deep flavor, no yucky bad-for-you oils, no separation. I love this product!

K
Kimberly Daily
Lives up to it’s Good Stuff name!

Gosh, what a difference from grocery store peanut butter!! It has a deeper roasted peanut flavor and the “chunky” pieces are smooth, not sharp. I’m so glad I discovered Good Stuff. I can feel good again about eating peanut butter!

K
Katie Brown
🙌

THE BEST!

A
Anonymous
I recd my first jar as a gift

I recd my first jar as a gift. I am hooked on it now. I purchased 2 since plus the Try Me pack to share.

A
Anonymous
It’s desert on a spoon…or on a date…or a Graham

It’s desert on a spoon…or on a date…or a Graham cracker😁Love it‼️

A
Anonymous
Delicious and quality ingredients!

Delicious and quality ingredients.
A real treat when I want something special that isn’t loaded with sugar!

A
Angela Flynn
Amazing peanut butter and

Amazing peanut butter and flavors

A
Anonymous
GreatPeanut Butter

First order appeared lost during shipment but a replacement was promptly sent. Peanut butter is great. I use it for medical purposes as the nuts used have a higher oleic acid content which is good for the liver.

D
Debbie Baisley
This is the best way to try out the flavors and see which ones you like best

This is the best way to try out the flavors and see which ones you like best. It’s also a nice way to get some smaller jars for gifting. This peanut butter is GREAT STUFF. I love that it not only tastes delicious, but it’s a healthier version of an all time favorite. Get some today. NOW.

G
Gary Troxler
Simply the

Simply the best!

A
Anonymous
Best peanut butter

Best peanut butter, ever!

A
Anonymous
It is the best peanut butter I’ve ever had!! I

It is the best peanut butter I’ve ever had!! I love it and I cannot wait for the mimy pb!!

A
April Clement

This one is my favorite! Soooo good! Love that it's all natural and organic and not sweetened with sugar!

A
April Clement

This is awesome! All of the flavors are amazing. It feels great, too, to be eating something healthy, yet it tastes so good.

C
C.B.
A favorite

It is a great product. Just the right amount of kick. Makes for a unique and delicious change of pace. Or a go to choice for heat lovers like my wife.

J
Jeff Mills
Choco Mocha is the bomb

My wife and I recently purchased a jar of your Choco Mocha at the Cheerwine Festival a couple of weeks ago and our only regret is that we didn’t buy two. We eat it out of the jar more than with anything else. Great product. We’ll be buying more. That’s for sure.