Know someone who eats peanut butter straight off the spoon? You're in luck: peanut butter makes a gift that's affordable, easy to ship, and actually gets used. Here are our favorite peanut butter gift ideas for the holidays, birthdays, or just because.
The easiest gift: the Try-Pack
Can't decide which flavor they'd like? Let them try three. Our Try-Pack comes with three 9 oz. jars in a custom gift box, in any combination of our five flavors. It's ready to give the moment it arrives.
- $25 per gift box
- Order 2 or more and save 10%. Perfect for knocking out several people on your list.
- We'll ship it straight to them with your greeting. Just check the gift box option and enter their address at checkout.
Back for the holidays: Chocolate Mint Crunch
Our seasonal favorite is coming back. Chocolate Mint Crunch blends rich chocolate, crushed organic peppermint and creamy peanut butter into a flavor that tastes like the holidays in a jar. It's a seasonal, limited run, so when it's gone, it's gone until next year.
Available November 1. Add a jar to any order for an instant stocking stuffer.
Peanut butter gifts by personality
For the cinnamon roll lover
Cinnamon Roll Crunch is our fan favorite: roasted peanut flavor meets fresh-baked cinnamon roll, with a satisfying crunch. Pair it with a bag of apples or a loaf of cinnamon raisin bread.
For the chocolate lover
Choco Mocha blends premium chocolate with a hint of crushed espresso bean. Add strawberries, pretzels or a bag of good coffee for a gift that feels indulgent.
For the hot sauce fan
Spicy Kick folds roasted, smoked habanero and jalapeño into creamy peanut butter for a mild, smoky heat. It's a fun surprise for anyone who puts hot sauce on everything. (Try it on a burger!)
For the peanut butter purist
Some people just want great peanut butter. Our Creamy and Crunchy are made with high oleic peanuts, slow roasted in small batches with a touch of wood smoked maple syrup. One taste and they'll know it's not grocery store peanut butter.
For the person who has everything
Go with the Try-Pack and pick one sweet, one classic and one spicy. It's a tasting experience in a box.
Gifts for teachers, coworkers and neighbors
A single 16 oz. jar with a bow makes a thoughtful, under-$15 gift. Ordering for a group? Free shipping kicks in on orders of $48 or more, and Try-Packs are 10% off when you order 2 or more.
Gift FAQ
Can you ship directly to the person I'm gifting?
Yes. Check the gift box option on the product page, add a short greeting, and enter their address at checkout. We'll take care of the rest.
How fresh will it be when it arrives?
Every jar is made fresh in North Carolina and ships fast. And because we use high oleic peanuts, it stays fresh longer.
Is shipping free?
Shipping is free on orders of $48 or more.
When should I order for the holidays?
Order by December 15 for delivery by Christmas. Ordering early is always a good idea, since holiday shipping gets busy.
Happy gifting! Shop all Good Stuff flavors.